Support ESC Insight on Patreon

Newsletter: Rehearsal Roundup – Big Five And Hosts Written by on May 11, 2019 | 7 Comments

As the open rehearsals come to an end we get our look at the Big Five and our Israeli hosts. In the latest newsletterJohn Lucas looks at the acts that are automatically through to Saturday’s Grand Final. Who’s on course and who has more work to do?

Warming Up…

France

The clear standout of the auto-qualifier rehearsals yesterday, Bilal’s aspirational anthem Roi has been given every opportunity to succeed by the French delegation. His vocals sound much stronger than the national final, a subtle remix has given the song more energy and the presence of two captivating onstage dancers communicate the message of the song effectively. Some of the other big 5 delegations should definitely be taking notes…

Israel

The home nation has suffered a fair amount of blowback from fans at home and abroad for following Netta’s bold modern pop with this old school stage ballad. However, to the production team’s credit, they’ve polished this stage show to near-perfection. It’s still a rather dated effort, but there’s a package here that could appeal to enough voters for Israel to avoid the bottom five. Considering the form of recent host nations, that’s a minor victory in itself.

Kobi Marimi rehearses for Eurovision 2019 (eurovision.tv/Andreas Putting)

Kobi Marimi rehearses for Eurovision 2019 (eurovision.tv/Andreas Putting)

Italy

Italy are wisely keeping things simple for the stage performance of Soldi. A combination of animations and some well-chosen English language translation appear on the LED backdrop to assist with storytelling, while Mahmood delivers a confident performance that feels more like a star turn at an awards show than a Eurovision hopeful fighting for attention in a field of 26.

Cooling Down…

Germany

After a welcome return to the top five in 2018, poor Germany look to be on a collision course for the bottom five again this year. The song remains as limp and lifeless as when it inexplicably won Unser Lied für Israel, and while the girls are delivering perfectly serviceable vocals, they’re left adrift by a dull and unimaginative stage show that ends with the ultimate admission of modern Eurovision defeat – the unearned Golden shower effect.

Sisters for Germany 2019 (eurovision.tv)

Sisters for Germany 2019 (eurovision.tv)

Spain

In the absence of a party anthem from Israel this year, Spain’s summery Iberian bop could fill the void quite nicely. Miki is certainly delivering on the energy, but the stage show feels seriously over-cooked. There’s flames, an oversized dollhouse, an actual wickerman and a lot of quite frenetic running about. There’s lots to enjoy here, but the overall impression is that a little bit of streamlining could go a long way.

United Kingdom

They say that the accepted definition of madness is doing the same thing over and over again while anticipating a different result. In the case of the United Kingdom, they seem to be stuck in a feedback loop of vaguely aspirational balladry. Everything about Michael Rice’s staging screams ‘X Factor Winners Single’, but sadly the overall effect is more Ben Haenow than Leona Lewis. He’s a gifted singer and by all accounts a lovely chap, but a fresh approach is needed.

You can stay up to date with all of the latest Eurovision news and analysis right here on ESC Insight. Sign up to the newsletter here, and you can also follow us on Facebook and Twitter

About The Author: John Lucas

A writer and content marketing professional with a passion for getting lost in strange cities and a strange fascination with micro states, John has been with ESC Insight since 2015 and has also had his writing featured in publications including The Guardian, Popjustice and So So Gay. Tweetable @JLucas86.

Read more from this author...

You Can Support ESC Insight on Patreon

ESC Insight's Patreon page is now live; click here to see what it's all about, and how you can get involved and directly support our coverage of your Eurovision Song Contest.

Share This Post

If You Like This...

Have Your Say

7 responses to “Newsletter: Rehearsal Roundup – Big Five And Hosts”

  1. Mark says:

    I think it’s possible that neither the UK or Germany will score any points. Which makes me think, do they even deserve a placing number? You can’t even finish last if you haven’t registered any kind of score.

  2. Ewan Spence says:

    In the unlikely event that there is a tiebreak on points, and both have the same number of televote points, and a countback of 12, 10, 8… etc does not break the tie (as in a double-nul) then I believe that the country which is earlier in the running order is given the higher placing.

  3. James says:

    Crossing fingers for the UK to do well this year. I don’t understand the utter dislike towards ballads in Eurovision. *sigh*

  4. rhk says:

    Ewan, you are correct. 2015: Austria and Germany both had nul points in the grand final. Austria finished “ahead” of Germany due to them performing 14th while Germany performed 17th.

  5. […] to ESC Insight for a thorough post-mortem on the results online and on the ESC Insight podcast. Check out the latest version of the ESC Insight newsletter here, or subscribe here to receive regular updates direct to your […]

  6. […] to ESC Insight for a thorough post-mortem on the results online and on the ESC Insight podcast. Check out the latest version of the ESC Insight newsletter here, or subscribe here to receive regular updates direct to your […]

  7. […] to ESC Insight for a thorough post-mortem on the results online and on the ESC Insight podcast. Check out the latest version of the ESC Insight newsletter here, or subscribe here to receive regular updates direct to your […]

Leave a Reply